Which ship for Bahamas - Florida port - Elation, Liberty, Freedom

[modernscarlett]

I've sailed on both classes of ship, and definitely prefer the Conquest class, but the Elation has 5 days rather than 4 day cruises.

 

The Liberty and Freedom seem basically the same, but having been on none of these, are there recommendations for which to choose?

 

TIA!

 

Lori

[Megan_Strick]

I've been on all and would choose Liberty or Freedom just because it is bigger.

[pirate4me2]

I would choose Liberty. She's bigger than  Elation, and when we did an 8 day cruise on her we had a great time. The decor is so pretty too....lots of wrought iron and color changing lights, very elegant! 

[CruiseAdict218]

Elation is certainly not a bad choice, sailed on her in Dec ‘21 and had a great time, ship is very beautiful on the inside. Little odd how quickly you can pass through the ship. 
 

Freedom is also a good choice, did that for the Sailabration and had a good time as well. Can’t comment on Liberty. 

[Megan_Strick]

6 minutes ago, CruiseAdict218 said:

Elation is certainly not a bad choice, sailed on her in Dec ‘21 and had a great time, ship is very beautiful on the inside. Little odd how quickly you can pass through the ship. 
 

Freedom is also a good choice, did that for the Sailabration and had a good time as well. Can’t comment on Liberty. 

Liberty is basically the same as the Freedom

[dlphn501]

If you really want the 5th day, then Elation.  I love the fantasy class ships, but I love Liberty as well.  It does have two extra (free) lunch venues as well - the bbq on the top deck of lido buffet, and Mongolian Wok.  If those don't matter, then price and/or location should prevail.  

[havanadaydreaming]

i'd definitely take the option with more days rather than selecting a ship.   

 

i have sailed Elation and she was fun.  different, but fun.  

 

I dont remember Liberty or Freedom but i'd have to check my signature to see if i've sailed them.  but im sure i sailed that class and enjoyed myself.  

 

not a bad option in the bunch in my opinion.   

[havanadaydreaming]

well...looks like Freedom and Liberty were my 2nd and 3rd cruises.  ha! 

 

thumbs up! 

 

[Saint Greg]

I would choose Freedom because it's newer and has more bells and whistles. Specifically for me, Red Frog Pub. If kids are involved, Waterworks.

[Drazil65]

Liberty or Freedom, we are not fans of the fantasy class of ships.  

[asalligo]

I have been on the Elation and the Liberty twice and I love them both, but the Liberty is better. Elation's refit was poorly conceived.