We enjoyed it and feel that we got great value for our money. We really loved getting the photos (no, we are not first time cruisers, but we have several digital frames, and sometimes it's nice to throw a cruise thumb drive in and watch). We both enjoy the finer wines and ports, so that absolutely helps out; Princess Prizes paid for itself in OBC (I won a total of $750 IIRC, and DH won an additional $500, not to mention the casino and I had a lovely time :D). We also enjoy our cocktails, so having the higher end liquors in those is helpful. We tried the desserts, they were nice; attended a couple of the yoga sessions...
I think that the only thing that we DIDN'T do was use the medallion accessory because we already had ours.
Have a great time and live your best life!