MDR dinner menus are usually fine for me, but the veggie options are often horrible and the vegan desserts are tasteless. However, the chips (with mayo) are always an alternative as they are very good on P&O. I find the MDR lunch menu nicer.
In my experience, Peninsular Club lunch is for Caribbean, Baltic and Ligurian. Last cruise on Aurora they had to have 4 lunches as so many in these tiers, but that is not unusual for Aurora.
Did Britannia and Royal Princess in 2015. Same ship but chalk and cheese. Love Britannia but did not like Royal. The latter had more cabins (more crowded), no Crows Nest or Sunset Bar. Not sailed Princess since.
Savers often get Freedom dining. If you get freedom you should be able to change it to club on board. Have done this a few times. 2nd sitting is the least popular so easiest to get, especially if you are wiling to share.
For heavens sake. You obviously have not cruised as much as you make out. Select allows you to choose fixed (first or second) or freedom and table size. Saver does not but you can almost always change what you get if not what you want once on board. I speak from experience. Sorry if this is disrepectful but your labouring of your points is getting a bit tedious!
Larger MDR for Freedom, smaller one for Fixed. Only queues are those couples who want tables for two in Freedom and want to dine at 6.00. They start queueing at 5.30. That's tea time for me!
Exhausting, yes. Let's all agree that we have different likes, dislikes, budgets, and needs. Thank goodness there are plenty of ships and cruising styles to choose from - at present!
Wrong again. As a previous poster said, on the smaller ships you are likely to just turn up and get a table or at least book a table at short notice as availability is more plentiful. Glasshouse in particular is easy to get in.