Depends on what kind of pie or what kind of cake?
Coconut cream pie, cherry pie, blueberry pie, apple pie, chocolate cream pie, banana cream pie? Absolutely!
Pumpkin pie? NO!
Chocolate layer cake, chocolate mousse cake, black forest cake, German chocolate cake, banana cake, homemade vanilla layer cake, coconut cake? Apple cake? berry filled cake? YES
Carrot cake, fruit cake? NO!
Sometimes it's all about what I crave and what's on the menu. If I'm craving dessert, I will certainly hope my only two menu options aren't carrot cake and pumpkin pie. At that point, I want to know what flavors of ice cream are on offer (and hope I have options other than vanilla).