Well, lo and behold, I have just looked at a few RSS reviews, as they seem to be fêted as a contrast to the poor aspects of Cunard. Now, I know from experience of the Cunard reviews how erratic reviews can be, but still. The average score is slightly lower than the Cunard average, and the reviewers, as on Cunard, are a mixture of those who had a gorgeous time, and those who were very dissatisfied often over pettifogging things, including the food. So I wonder where you might even find a luxury line.