First cruise on Celebrity after over 25 cruises on HAL and Princess. Yes, ship is in great shape. Staff great. MDR entrees better than Princess. Did not like Ocean View Cafe. No flow and people bumping into each other. Comedian magician great and OK for family. Expected a quieter crowd - I believe the "all in" contributed to the noise level. Unfortunately all ABC ports have changed entry into the towns since we last visited, making for long walks - in the rain and wind. Shuttles, as in many other ports, would have been appreciated. Princess and HAL have more venues for entertainment. The singer from the Celebrity band sang "At last" - one of the best I have ever heard. So, for the most part, positive, but our next cruise will be back to Princess.