We were cruising about the same time as you...only on Norwegian Joy in the Haven.
Our cruise was over-run with kids....too many were out of control. How was MSC?
We've been in the Yacht Club twice and will probably book with them again soon.
Hopefully, they haven't downgraded their YC experience since we last cruised with them (pre-pandemic). I did read they no longer have the chocolate ship.😮
I know their prices have gone up!
NCL's Haven. The only problem is the Haven restaurant's menu doesn't change. So you are "stuck" having prime rib, filet mignon and lobster every night.