Excellent, fair review! We've been on Mardi Gras twice and are booked again for December. We'll avoid Spring Break in the future but absolutely love the ship. Too bad you didn't get to go to Red Frog Tiki, it was our favorite daytime bar. At night, it was Fortune Teller, Alchemy, Bar Della Rosa (and coffee in the mornings). I really liked Brass Magnolia but as it worked out, we only went once each cruise. We like the Pig & Anchor space a lot and loved the bartenders there. The food is just so inconsistent. We had a couple good meals and one not so good.