Please help! Nassau or Roatan???

[ireland666666]

:confused: I dont know which cruise to book- either one that goes to Grand Cayman, Belize, Roatan and Cozumel - OR- one that goes to Cozumel, Belize, Costa Maya and Nassau. Which one should I choose???

[nursebubba]

Oh my no question. Roatan. Nassau has no good snorkeling. There is a beach on Roatan called Tabyana. We usu do not do ship excursions but this one is worth it. It is like another private island day.

[Loving My Life]

Absolutely Roatan!!

[Krazy Kruizers]

DEfinitely the one with Roatan -- been there a couple of times -- love it!!

[Kristi Williamson]

ROATAN!! It's apples and oranges! Promise.

[NCTribeFan]

I'm not a Nassau hater. In fact, I rather like it. Will be there for the 4th time in a couple of months. And I don't go to Atlantis and I'm not a shopper, either. I just like it there.

 

BUT, we stopped in Roatan in May and I loved it.

 

I haven't been to Costa Maya, so I'd like to see it, too, but I'd take the cruise that goes to Roatan.

 

We (DD & I) rented a female driver through Diana & Cinthia. She took us to the Iguana Farm, then a shop, then to the west end area to Foster's West Bay Resort. It was gorgeous.

 

Haven't been to Grand Cayman in ages, so would like to return there. Belize is also wonderful.

[eandj]

Most definitely the Roatan cruise. :)

[LiznMartin]

Not been to Naussau but LOVED Roatan :) Would love to go back again one day.

[firefly333]

This is a no brainer. I think the Bahamas were dissapointing when I first went there in the late 80s, hoped I was wrong, been back and they still are dissapointing.

 

Roatan is really beautifull. I picked a date that goes to Roatan on purpose, and cant wait to go back for a 3rd time.

[capncarp]

Roatan is my choice--still has lots of natural beauty, the snorkelling has great reputation, its people are friendly, the pace is mellow.:cool:

 

If you're looking for something more sophisticated, commercial, and modern in a port, then Nassau would be your choice.

[3GR8Sons]

Roatan is my favorite Carribean port. Nothing wrong with Nassau, but Roatan is really different.

[paul929207]

I, too, will vote for Roatan.

[ireland666666]

Roatan it is!!!!!! THANKS EVERYONE!

[TakeMeAway1001]

I agree Roatan, it was the stop I was least anticipating but we had an amazing time. We booked a private tour with Victor Bodden and our driver Tex took us sighseeing and we ended up at a beach right next to Tabyana. We got to drop our stuff and rent snorkel gear for $5 p/p, I posted some pictures in my review at the bottom of my signature. It was a great port and we plan on going back soon :)