Thanks for sharing. I don’t know your demographic, but as a Gen Xer myself, here is my personal view to a few points of yours.
1. SS already limits dining requests submitted in advance of one’s voyage. So, I’d hate to see SS impose further limitations. With that said, I would have no issue with the complete removal of the dining request system in order to return to the days of old where one could dine when and wherever they’d like, with whomever they liked.
2. For those who enjoy morning and afternoon excursions, it can be a challenge to catch lunch. By closing an indoor venue such as La Terrazza or The Restaurant even earlier than it already does would make it even more difficult to have lunch, let alone limiting the variety such action would cause.
5. I agree, it’s VACATION. For those of us who work, it’s all casual, all the time. At least it is in the vastness of corporate America these days. We choose SS for the very reason you despise. The dress code is already super relaxed as it’s only a night or two where people dress up and even on those nights there are options where people can dine who don’t want to dress up. As a man, wearing a jacket to dinner for a hour or two never gets old. And as far as your claim that younger passengers are turned off by the dress code, I disagree. Every Millennial or Gen Zer I’ve met on SS said they actually enjoy the dress code. Why? Because their professional lives are already steeped in casualness. As such, SS is one of the few elegant vacations choices they have in a sea of sameness amongst luxury cruise lines. I’d suggest men who tire of wearing a jacket to dinner on vacation more than a couple of nights have a plethora of vacation choices to select from, including many cruise lines, and as such, are not solely limited to SS.
In closing, thank you for sharing your personal view. I hope you will accept mine in the same vein you offered yours.