I would like to thank the OP for this post and others as the replies are VERY helpful.
Dedicated Carnival cruiser here. We love it and complain about very little while on vacation. Matter of fact, I personally loathe people who travel and then complain about this or that the whole time. Vacation for us is a true sacrifice, and I refuse to spend it upset about petty things. That said, Carnival is very familiar to us. We are wanting to try something new. As others have said, MSC stands out for us right now, because their pricing is pretty dang good. Even leaving from New York, which would be fantastic!
So long as the kids have food to eat (teenagers) and we can relax, we should be good. Be nice to try something different.
Can someone tell me about the easy drink package and if there are enough basic choices to choose from? And also, can you load your onboard account with cash? One more thing, do you think there's alot onboard to spend extra on or is the included food and treats sufficient? This will help with planning our budget. TIA!