O'Sheehan's Menu? Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

[ready2cruzagain]

Tried looking for a current O'Sheehan's menu and having no luck finding one.  Does O'Sheehan's still have the hot roast beef sandwich?

[ready2cruzagain]

Forget it, just found a new one on Youtube.And my answer is YES!

[shof515]

i had the hot roast beef sandwhich on the Norwegian Dawn and it reminds me like those Arby roast beef sandwich. for me, i did not like it

[ready2cruzagain]

11 minutes ago, shof515 said:

i had the hot roast beef sandwhich on the Norwegian Dawn and it reminds me like those Arby roast beef sandwich. for me, i did not like it

 

DH loves them but I personally prefer the Salmon Ceasar Salad. 

[mking8288]

Still offered, available, no upcharge 😜 2 weeks ago (last year) on the Gem.  Served warm, it was okay, but not impressed vs. getting one around here. We don't cruise for food, as options are subjective.

 

 

[ready2cruzagain]

10 minutes ago, mking8288 said:

Still offered, available, no upcharge 😜 2 weeks ago (last year) on the Gem.  Served warm, it was okay, but not impressed vs. getting one around here. We don't cruise for food, as options are subjective.

 

 

 

Thank you for the picture, DH appreciates it (he is drooling LOL).  We don't cruise for food either, nowadays we cruise for the ship.  DH likes the RB as a change from the wings and salads at O'Sheehans.  When you are on a ship for 21 days you get to try a lot of different things that you would not normally eat on a short cruise.

[ColeThornton]

That's some really pathetic looking roast beef.

[schmoopie17]

1 hour ago, ColeThornton said:

That's some really pathetic looking roast beef.

 

Somebody actually compared that disgusting-looking slop to Arby's.

I haven't been to Arby's in years, but if that's what their stuff looks like, it's a wonder they've stayed in business this long.

 

[mking8288]

1 hour ago, ColeThornton said:

That's some really pathetic looking roast beef.

 

I almost spilled my morning coffee ... Happy New Year.  Not your "fault" at all. That's why we are critics.

[shof515]

1 hour ago, ColeThornton said:

That's some really pathetic looking roast beef.

and its tasteless too. it like those frozen steakums pieces or whatever it is called

[ready2cruzagain]

DH says he might not get it now after all of your reactions 🤣 He said the picture does not look as good as he remembers 😂

[Debde]

Oh My. 🤢  So not a good promo for the Roast beef sandwich!!  🤣

 

Now I've had the Hot Turkey Sandwich and it was good and looked good too!!    Food starts at about 1:30 Hot turkey at about 2:40

 

[FLAHAM]

I tried the shepherd's pie on my September cruise.  Evidently, the shepherds in NCL land herd cattle, not sheep. 

[mking8288]

1 hour ago, ready2cruzagain said:

DH says he might not get it now after all of your reactions 🤣 He said the picture does not look as good as he remembers 😂

 

It was #cough #cough, a notch or two ... better last January on the Escape.  I had to dig into our photo archieve to see if we ate there & ordered it.  Here's what it looked like - could be deceiving due to lighting.  If they've pop it into a microwave for 30 seconds first before bring it out as a hot sandwich - would probably made a difference.  For a ship like the Gem or Dawn, there is no excuse with their own small gallery for a lurk warm sandwich - when the deep fried wings came out hot.  I wouldn't try to compare it to Arby's and risk walking the NCL gang plank next time (just kidding ...)  

 

DW ordered hot turkey sandwich - and it was good, better than mine.  Probably the same grade of red meat as provisioned ... maybe, the difference is in the skills of the chef in the preparation as "presented" .  

I dunno, very subtle difference ... let the jury decide.  

 

[Gershep]

I would go with the open turkey, the open roast beef I ordered on the Escape in September was nothing but fat. I could not eat it.

[ready2cruzagain]

1 hour ago, Gershep said:

I would go with the open turkey, the open roast beef I ordered on the Escape in September was nothing but fat. I could not eat it.

 

DH said he tried the open faced turkey sandwich but he thought it was "Fowl" tasting 🤣

[ready2cruzagain]

1 hour ago, mking8288 said:

 

 

 

 

That looks a lot better than the first picture...I will have to take a picture next week on the Breakaway!

[Debde]

Yes-picture #2 is definitely better looking then picture #1. I'm all about comfort food so I will probably do the hot open turkey again. Roast beef can be fatty so I guess it's luck of the draw.

 

4 hours ago, FLAHAM said:

I tried the shepherd's pie on my September cruise.  Evidently, the shepherds in NCL land herd cattle, not sheep. 

 

I love Sheperd's pie and do not eat lamb so I'll be thrilled if it's made with beef only!! 😀

 

[shof515]

54 minutes ago, Debde said:

I love Sheperd's pie and do not eat lamb so I'll be thrilled if it's made with beef only!! 😀

 

i am the same way too..i hate lamb..would love to see a beef version of shepherd pie

[PortFees45]

10 hours ago, mking8288 said:

Still offered, available, no upcharge 😜 2 weeks ago (last year) on the Gem.  Served warm, it was okay, but not impressed vs. getting one around here. We don't cruise for food, as options are subjective.

 

 

 

That looks absolutely vile. 

[Sauer-kraut]

Whenever I've made Shepherd's Pie, I have only used ground beef.  My mom's classic recipe calls for beef as well.

[meatball_nyc]

Never mind the roast beef...

Wish O’Sheehan’s would bring back their chicken pot pie...

IMHO it was really good. 

🥳 Happy New Year to Everyone 🐔

 

Edited to add : I have to get back to work tomorrow and am pretty grouchy about it. 

Edited January 2, 2020 by meatball_nyc
why are all the summer of 2020 Encore to Bermuda prices so $$$?

[cementhands]

12 hours ago, ready2cruzagain said:

Tried looking for a current O'Sheehan's menu and having no luck finding one.  Does O'Sheehan's still have the hot roast beef sandwich?

Never tried that, yet. Maybe next cruise. Can’t get away from the chicken wings. Dry with sauce on side. 

[mking8288]

55 minutes ago, meatball_nyc said:

... Wish O’Sheehan’s would bring back their chicken pot pie ... IMHO it was really good. 

🥳 Happy New Year to Everyone 🐔

... have to get back to work tomorrow and am pretty grouchy about it. 

 

HNY to you, Robin ...  I concur, chicken pot pie over Sheperd's pie anytime - as one of my personal favorite on a NCL cruise.   Yeah, I hear ya on going back to work but only 2 more days to the weekend.  

 

Nevermind the Bliss prices for this summer, it's crazy high for 4 days and 5 days island run to Bermuda & back for April.  Going with Plan C this Spring, an oversea trip - flying & land-based tour - real "street food, perhaps" not the Norwegian way (if you saw that recent post)

 

42 minutes ago, cementhands said:

Never tried that, yet. Maybe next cruise. Can’t get away from the chicken wings. Dry with sauce on side. 

 

In all fairness as a balanced critic, OSH wings were good and fine with us. Sauce on the side ... the blue cheese dressing or whatever for the celery worked fine.  Just don't let them drown the poultry in their sauces ... If NCL wanted to do spicy chicken, take a hint at Popoyes - they got it right, with a choice of "mild" vs. "spicy".  

Edited January 2, 2020 by mking8288

[MoniMommy]

I had the roast beef sandwich on my cruise last month on GEM. It was room temperature and had no taste. I just ate the mashed potatoes and broccoli. I would have ordered something else but didn't feel like waiting another 30 minutes for it to arrive.