We went back to AQ for the Eclipse holiday cruise next year after being in sky suites on Summit, Equinox and Sillie. The first two had butlers. The Sillie TA last month did not and it was a difference. We also enjoyed one meal in Blu and the food was outstanding. We've done ten AQ cruises and trading the Retreat for unlimited PG is a trade off we're happy with, especially on non-Revolutionized vessels. When Bermuda opens next week we'll try to snag the same room. For what =X= wants for a suite, we've already sought other lines and booked Oceania, Ponant and Regent on future suite voyages.