Currently, the Island is our least favorite ship in the Princess fleet. Once upon a time it was one of our favorite ships. IMHO, the cabin additions and moving the Fitness Center to Deck 5 was a major mistake which Princess acknowledged by canceling the same modifications to the Coral.
With all of this being said, we are booked on the Island for the March of 2026, 54-day, roundtrip Los Angeles voyage. The itinerary trumps the negative aspects of the ship. 🙂