Pets On Board RCC Cruise

[chengkp75]

I wonder if that applies in the Galveston, TX port. They control the liquor there using local laws.

 

I think my statement was a little simplistic. Local law governs out to the 12 mile limit. However, in Specter v. NCL, the US Supreme Court ruling that found that foreign flag cruise ships had to comply with some aspects of the ADA, the court ruled that without a clear decision by Congress to the effect that all aspects of the ADA would apply to foreign ships, that the cruise line's internal operating policies and procedures (i.e. having to provide hearing devices or allowing service animals throughout the ship) were none of the court's business. To date, Congress has not amended the ADA to specifically include foreign flag ships, which is why the settlement between Carnival and the DOJ surprises me in many of its aspects.

[xxoocruiser]

And once the animal sets paw onboard, any state or local laws go out the window, and only the ADA applies, as the ship is foreign territory.

 

Furthermore ADA only applies if the ship actually embarks from a USA Port.

[ryano]

We cruise to get AWAY from our pets, no rescue, no emails begging us to save this dog/cat, no vet visits, no cleaning, scooping, medicating, no being woken up at 3 am because two of them decide to try to kill each other, etc. I am happy to be away from the little ingrates for 8-9 days :D

 

We love our furbabies but we also love leaving them behind for those much needed, once a year cruises :p

 

I totally agree. I have a 100% legit service dog that is trained to do numerous tasks for me. It would be almost impossible to love a dog as much as I love my Allie but its like having a child. We need a break once in a while! So when I cruise, she stays with her trainer and is just happy as can be. Even though she is very well trained, I would never subject her to such close quarters and thousands of people. Plus I refuse to be glared at by dog haters. I dont notice it out in public nor could I care less but Im sure I would notice it on a ship.

 

Also, shes a Lab that has a HUGE love for water. It would be hard keeping her out of the pool :D:o

 

Here is Allie at my job, a college, where everyone loves her. When I cruise, she stays on land though. :)

 

[chengkp75]

Furthermore ADA only applies if the ship actually embarks from a USA Port.

 

Yep, which is why so many people are upset when the European river cruises don't meet the ADA. I haven't thought about it, but that would discount all cruises starting in Canada from having to meet the ADA, though the ships usually change home port seasonally, so they would eventually embark in the US.

[reallyitsmema]

I totally agree. I have a 100% legit service dog that is trained to do numerous tasks for me. It would be almost impossible to love a dog as much as I love my Allie but its like having a child. We need a break once in a while! So when I cruise, she stays with her trainer and is just happy as can be. Even though she is very well trained, I would never subject her to such close quarters and thousands of people. Plus I refuse to be glared at by dog haters. I dont notice it out in public nor could I care less but Im sure I would notice it on a ship.

 

Also, shes a Lab that has a HUGE love for water. It would be hard keeping her out of the pool :D:o

 

Here is Allie at my job, a college, where everyone loves her. When I cruise, she stays on land though. :)

 

 

She has gotten so big! I remember when you posted a picture of her when she was just a puppy and hadn't gone to school yet.:)

[Smiley4]

Was just on the Oasis of the Seas and a lady had a dog with her. The 4 by 4 area was on deck 5, right off the exercise track near the outdoor steps that went up to deck 6. There was a 4 by 4 area of grass and a 4 by 4 area of dirt. I guess the dog gets a choice lol.

[puppylove966]

I totally agree. I have a 100% legit service dog that is trained to do numerous tasks for me. It would be almost impossible to love a dog as much as I love my Allie but its like having a child. We need a break once in a while! So when I cruise, she stays with her trainer and is just happy as can be. Even though she is very well trained, I would never subject her to such close quarters and thousands of people. Plus I refuse to be glared at by dog haters. I dont notice it out in public nor could I care less but Im sure I would notice it on a ship.

 

 

 

Also, shes a Lab that has a HUGE love for water. It would be hard keeping her out of the pool :D:o

 

 

 

Here is Allie at my job, a college, where everyone loves her. When I cruise, she stays on land though. :)

 

 

 

 

 

 

She is so cute :) labs are the best dogs!

[ryano]

She has gotten so big! I remember when you posted a picture of her when she was just a puppy and hadn't gone to school yet.:)

 

4 years old now! time is passing by so fast!

[Garavar]

I would rather be on a ship with dogs than kids...but to each their own right.

 

For some people, their dogs are like kids to them or maybe the only companion they have in life.

 

Based on my experience I have seen with dogs on board, they are much quieter, well behaved and cuter than most kids.....actually compared to a lot of adults on board as well...lol

 

That should get some responses....but its my opinion just like those who don't like or think dogs should be on ships.....fair is fair!

 

Touchè! I stick to the smaller ships and off season so the amount of kids are reduced. The skee ball machine in the video arcades are mine! All mine!

[xxoocruiser]

And I believe its against the law for anyone to ask for further paper work to prove that the animal is a service dog.

 

Honestly, I think its absolutely terrible (if its not really a service dog).

 

You are correct that requesting documentation violates ADA Law.

 

Per the USA Department of Justice with reference to ADA Law in situations where it is not obvious that the dog is a service animal, staff may ask only two specific questions:

• Is the dog a service animal required because of a disability?
  
• What work or task has the dog been trained to perform?
  

Staff are not allowed to request any documentation for the dog, require that the dog demonstrate its task, or inquire about the nature of the person's disability.

Edited December 17, 2015 by xxoocruiser

[Don Pedro]

While a few people may abuse the real definition of a service dog in order to take their beloved Fido on a cruise, the ports of call are not nearly as accommodating as the cruise line. Some, like Jamaica, refuse to let any animal, service or not, into their country. Others charge a hefty fee. I believe Cayman Island is $150. Most also require a current veterinarian certificate.

[chengkp75]

The DOJ settlement was ghastly considering that the ships aren't US flagged and don't operate primarily in the US (just embarkation and disembarkation and sometimes a US port).

 

That being said, the settlement was recent (6 months ago?) and you better believe the conniving wolves at the DOJ will jump on as many financial settlements as possible with all the cruiselines that port in the US.

 

I believe that disabled people should have options -- but I also know more than a few personal contacts whose so-called disabilities create an unrealistic burden on businesses.

 

While I applaud the action to provide more and varied accessible cabins, I feel that the settlement, which essentially places the ships completely under the ADA's full provisions goes too far. I know that some HAL or Princess ships have a lounge that is currently only accessible via stairs. How much is it going to cost to make this one venue totally accessible?

[cruisevv]

I would rather be on a ship with dogs than kids...but to each their own right.

 

 

If it was any other situation, I'd agree but dogs in close proximity to each other tend to howl and bark and growl. Can you imagine the ruckus of multiple dogs were on balconies or started barking through the walls. There's also the issue of defecation outside of the 'relief areas'. With kids that have the same issue they seem to mostly segregated in the royal babies areas. I only once had an issue of a crying baby on my last trip for instance. For dogs, especially service ones, that's a little more difficult.

[Lionesss]

With all the strict guidelines of trying to maintain cleanliness I wonder who is responsible for "cleaning" up after the service dog?

 

Do they have a special walk area.............I

 

I guess what I am questioning is if a person is truly debilitated and needs the service dog for assistance...........who services the dogs......um bathroom needs, for clean-up?

 

Thanks

[Clarea]

With all the strict guidelines of trying to maintain cleanliness I wonder who is responsible for "cleaning" up after the service dog?

 

Do they have a special walk area.............I

 

I guess what I am questioning is if a person is truly debilitated and needs the service dog for assistance...........who services the dogs......um bathroom needs, for clean-up?

 

Thanks

There is a small area, usually on the outside promenade deck, for the dog to do their thing. Crew cleans this area.

Edited December 17, 2015 by clarea

[RealNorwegianCruiser]

I would rather be on a ship with dogs than kids...but to each their own right.

 

 

 

Agree!

[chengkp75]

With all the strict guidelines of trying to maintain cleanliness I wonder who is responsible for "cleaning" up after the service dog?

 

Do they have a special walk area.............I

 

I guess what I am questioning is if a person is truly debilitated and needs the service dog for assistance...........who services the dogs......um bathroom needs, for clean-up?

 

Thanks

 

Trained service dogs are trained to go only on command and/or on a specific substance. Either the disabled person or their companions are responsible for walking the dog and taking care of it's bathroom needs. This is not the crews responsibility. The ship will provide a "litter box" in an out of the way area of the promenade deck, which will be serviced by the crew a couple of times a day. The clean-up must be "red bagged" in biohazard bags, and burned in the incinerator. These requirements are all part of the USPH sanitation program.

[Don Pedro]

With all the strict guidelines of trying to maintain cleanliness I wonder who is responsible for "cleaning" up after the service dog?

 

Do they have a special walk area.............I

 

I guess what I am questioning is if a person is truly debilitated and needs the service dog for assistance...........who services the dogs......um bathroom needs, for clean-up?

 

Thanks

As some have pointed out people need service dogs for varying reasons. Most, although they have a disability, can still maintain their animal. Additionally most will be traveling with a friend or family member who can assist them. They may only need the service animal if they are alone. The crew cleans out the litter box which is typically located near an aft stair case on the promenade deck. An area not often frequented by passengers.

[jnojr]

 

Ships aren't exactly the best place for animals.

 

This. I love my girl, but would never want to bring her with.

[CaribSailor]

I would rather be on a ship with dogs than kids...but to each their own right.

 

 

 

For some people, their dogs are like kids to them or maybe the only companion they have in life.

 

 

 

Based on my experience I have seen with dogs on board, they are much quieter, well behaved and cuter than most kids.....actually compared to a lot of adults on board as well...lol

 

 

 

That should get some responses....but its my opinion just like those who don't like or think dogs should be on ships.....fair is fair!

 

 

Perhaps you should go on a line that is NOT family oriented then.. It's your own fault that you choose to go on a cruise line that caters to kids...everyone has a choice right?? I mean unless you are some weirdo who has a Shrek fetish. And if that is the case I wouldn't want you around my kid or my dogs..[emoji12][emoji41][emoji108]🏻[emoji23] [emoji90][emoji240]

[njmomof2]

I have no problem with service dogs anywhere. They provide a vital service to those who need them and should be allowed anywhere the individual needs to go.

 

That said, while I also recognize that often, a dog may perform a service that is not readily apparent (unlike a dog for a sight impaired individual, or ryano's dog), if the dog can detect a seizure before it happens, or recognize a blood sugar issue for its owner, would you expect that the owner would dress the dog up in a sailor suit and bring it to a restaurant in a baby stroller, where it slept the entire meal? This is what I saw on Freedom in August.

 

My friend has 2 dogs, neither of which have been trained or are certified service animals. Yet one of them somehow detected that my friend's blood sugar was dangerously low (she had fallen asleep on the couch and is a diabetic). The dog barked and pulled at her until she roused enough from her sleep to realize something was very wrong. Had she not, she may very well have died, as she lives alone. So sometimes our animals surprise us with skills we never knew they had.

 

Ryano, I can't see the picture of your wonderful dog (will try from home) but know that Allie must be very special. Anyone who watches The Today Show has been watching Wrangler, their golden retriever, who is being trained to assist a sight impaired individual. He's really terrific and I think it's great that they are getting the word out about the organizations that provide these special animals to people who need them.

Edited December 17, 2015 by njmomof2

[setsail]

There were 3 dogs on our allure cruise. The captain stated they were all service dogs. I heard one left a deposit in an elevator:p

[Retired LEO]

That "certification" isnt worth the paper its written on :) Besides, no one can require any type of certification.

 

That was my point. The whole "Service Dog" thing is a farce. For a price you can pretend to have a service dog.

Edited December 17, 2015 by Retired LEO

[goneclear]

A couple years ago while sailing on the liberty we saw a couple with a service dog. My wife and i love dogs so one day we got talking to them. We noticed the dog had a Diamond sea pass card around his neck but theirs was not. They said RCL gave the dog 7 sea days for every one human day and thats how he accumulated a higher C & A status than them.

We found that so cool of RCL.

The dog had his own online blog of his adventures and cruises but cant remember his name now.

We did see a 4ft by 4ft block of sod with grass outside the back of the ship on deck 4 and figured that was for him .

[Garavar]

A couple years ago while sailing on the liberty we saw a couple with a service dog. My wife and i love dogs so one day we got talking to them. We noticed the dog had a Diamond sea pass card around his neck but theirs was not. They said RCL gave the dog 7 sea days for every one human day and thats how he accumulated a higher C & A status than them.

We found that so cool of RCL.

The dog had his own online blog of his adventures and cruises but cant remember his name now.

We did see a 4ft by 4ft block of sod with grass outside the back of the ship on deck 4 and figured that was for him .

 

If the dog stays in a Suite does he get 14 days per day? Dog would be Pinnacle in 50 Days.

 

I wonder how that works out too, what if his owners are Emerald and he is Diamond. Do they have to wait outside the Diamond Lounge?