We did the 1/2-day excursion to Amiga Island in 2016 and it was wonderful....but I would not do it again.....there was zero security when we were there then, not sure if they have any now. We had locals in small boats trying to sell us fish/lobsters and they came right up to us while we were swimming. Looking back, I feel pretty naive that I allowed this happen to my loved ones and myself....but when you are on vacation, often times you let your guard down and doent think straight. We have been back to Labadee a few times since then and enjoy it but would never do another excursion outside the main area again.