We have been on all of them, Freedom a lot since it came to Miami. Freedom is updated with a great colorful pool area, El Loco Fresh and the Lime and Coconut Bar. Also love Playmakers on her. But we are doing Liberty in Dec/Jan/Feb/Mar because it is out of FLL vs Miami and that saves us travel time and great offsite parking rather than Miami where we park at the port, since offsite parking in Miami is horrible. Liberty has Saturday Night Fever, which we love. Freedom does not have a major production show. We like them all, so really just go with what works for you.