We sailed last month and I wanted the Cattier since they no longer have Montaudon. They told me that Chandon is on the premium package, which it is, but I wanted champagne and not sparkling wine, especially if paying for the premium package. They did find Cattier sometime during the cruise, but also had something called Blue Top, which was pretty good. Who knows what is there now. Some people were very upset. One night the sommelier stood next to me and thanked me for not being mad at him while others were going off on his boss after they yelled at him. We sail in a couple of weeks and I have no idea what to expect