HELP - Opinions please, which shoe??

[Loves_Dogs]

Which shoes would you wear with this navy blue dress (will be wearing to a wedding)?

1 - black pump

2 - navy blue wedge

3 - black/rhinestone pump

4 - blush color with square heel

Thank you!

[crystalspin]

4. Seconded by 2,

 

I'm old enough not to want to wear black with navy.

 

ETA: Great dress!

Edited October 1, 2023 by crystalspin

[PurpleHays]

#2 because I'm more stable in wedges and they're more comfortable.

[awhfy]

I wore those wedges (in cream) to a wedding, they’re super comfortable 

[57redbird]

#2

[aungrl]

#2

[Lois R]

#2 for me as well

 

[mrgabriel]

Definitely 4. Navy is my black and I used to always wear navy shoes with navy dresses and trousers but now I prefer something that pops - not matches - so my shoes are more of an accessory. 

[crystalspin]

If you are BUYING new shoes, I heavily favor #4. They will go with anything. Whereas navy shoes go with navy, some reds or pinks, some prints.

[Lois R]

I can't wear an ankle strap like the other photos and I prefer a wedge, that is why I chose #2.

[awhfy]

1 hour ago, Lois R said:

I can't wear an ankle strap like the other photos and I prefer a wedge, that is why I chose #2.

Me too

[Loves_Dogs]

Thank you so much everyone for your help! I have ordered 2 and 4. Once I get them I plan to walk around in them inside and see which I am more comfortable with as I rarely dress up and never wear heels.

[CunucuMom]

4 hours ago, Loves_Dogs said:

Thank you so much everyone for your help! I have ordered 2 and 4. Once I get them I plan to walk around in them inside and see which I am more comfortable with as I rarely dress up and never wear heels.

Both 2 and 4 are really cute and I can vouch for the comfort of the #2 brand (Karen Scott).  I don't wear heels since I retired and bought these t-straps for our cruise last month.  Wore them straight out of the box 2-3 nights (what was I thinking??), up and down multiple flights of stairs with no issues except they were sometimes slippery on polished floors.  Either of your choices will work beautifully with the gorgeous navy dress!

[crystalspin]

23 hours ago, Lois R said:

I can't wear an ankle strap like the other photos and I prefer a wedge, that is why I chose #2.

The wedge (#2) in the color of #4 would be the best of both worlds!

[simplelife]

The navy wedge is the winner for both color and style.

 

. The black pump does not look dressy enough for the dress. Heavy-looking.

 

The black rhinestone shoe is a great style but would be better in navy or silver.

 

The Blush one is just a NO.

 

[sjb317]

I am certainly not an expert on style  but  I would not wear  any of the shoes with your dress. I would look for something sparkly, probably silver.  I really like the shoes pictured with the dress so I would go for something similar.

 
I love your dress!

 

Sherri🙂

[Mum2Mercury]

I like all, especially #3 and 4 ... but I'd rather see a pair with a thinner /more delicate ankle strap.  The hemline is fairly long, so that chunkier ankle strap "chops the leg in half".  

 

I'd also prefer something in all silver or all gold (with the dress being a solid color, a little bling would be a nice addition), though the cream shoe above is more practical.  

Edited October 15, 2023 by Mum2Mercury