We've done three New Years cruises, had lots of fun, did the count down around the pool. Great way to ring in the New Year, you'll have stories to tell for years.
In your screen shot I'm surprised you got your Doc's because you have a red warning under passport. Mine would not let me go all the way to Doc's if the others were not completed.
I have never been asked by a crew member for a positive review, and would not if asked by a crew member. But I always mention by name those that gave good service on post cruise survey.