MsTabbyKats

I'm not saying I'd be happy with $200 (unfair to ask me...I hate cold weather....I'd never go to Greenland) but can a cruise really be called "a destination cruise" with all the variables that could happen? People should be aware of this when they book....ports are at the mercy of the weather etc. IMHO...if you want to see Greenland, or AnyLand....plan a trip to that land. At best, you can get a couple of hours and the bragging rights that you stepped foot there on a cruise. Planning a cruise for any specific port is risky.... Maybe @Eli_6 couple lead a class action (joking....)

@Eli_6I never heard of the Dunning Krueger effect, but now that I know it, I'm gonna be using it a lot....lol.

I had some internet issues and the YC concierge desk was able to help. Glad you're enjoying the cruise.

@mking8288As an official YC cheerleader, the cost of an interior YC is about equal to a sailaway balcony on NCL. And you really don't need a balcony....a dedicated YC elevator is about 30 seconds away....to the 30 second ride to the YC pool deck. There is no comparison between the experiences. We did an inside guarantee on NCL a few years ago (5?)....and after that disaster of a cabin, never again (the tiniest cabin ever with no storage space). Just wasn't worth it to save $$$. We have a CCL to the Bahamas booked for Jan....after that it' "YC Forever"! DH is using a cane now...and I have to compliment NCL employees coming to his assistance just about everywhere. Also...fellow passengers were always offering him their seats (lol....obviously not locals). He used the WC embarkationj, but it was a long wait. For disembarkation, we saw the line waiting the wheelchairs...so he walked off (slowly). But the bottom line is, YC was just oh so much better. To note...I had looked into the Haven for the Escape sailing but you don't get nearly as much as what the YC offers....and for the cost, no thank you!

@Eli_6I will admit....Carnival messed up on a good pr opportunity. Offer a generous FCC...(raise the prices of course)....and people won't want to miss out on using a credit.

Well...I personally would have done my research and found out that I booked an old boat that was about to go into dry dock....going to Greenland, and I would have not booked the cruise. It's called "personal responsibiltiy" and I'd be angry at myself...for being stupid.

Which is why I check credit cards....daily.

Even so....the cruise line really owes you nothing, Historically, I've found Carnival to be more generous than other cruiselines.

Do you think another cruiseline would have "sailed thru the storm"? Ports are not guaranteed. Period. If you want "a port"....book a land vacation. It's just luck. We were on NCL Escape 9/3 to Canada...it was like cruising in the Caribbean; perfect weather. The next week, same ship, same itinerary....missed 2 ports and floated off the coast of NYC for 2 additional sea days.

People who live in houses are unaware that they are making noise. Knock on the door and ask if they oculd be more mindful.

@mking8288When you met the car service, where exactly did they pick you up? Second floor of terminal?

@Crusin KarenIf we go, we'll be getting on when you're getting off. (Decided to wait until last minute to cancel) I'm really probably overthinking this...... I see you responded on my separate thread. Thanks!

Most likely they'll match you to gold... The only Diamond benefit is a meal....no extra discounts. MSC doesn't allow non YC passengers into the YC....even to look around. If you can...go for YC interior. It's the best value at sea...in my opinion anyway.

@Haljo1935Will be following this closely..... "To cancel or not to cancel" Jan cruise depends on you! If you can...please report back about lines in the buffet and slippery conditions on the Lido Enjoy your trip!

But NCL's been phasing out good entertainment....imho. Putting in magicians and comediens, audience particiapation games. Last week on the Escape we skipped the theartre several evenings. MSC concentrates on "non verbal" entertainment because of the multi-language issue. For the record...I'm a B'way fan....once a month or so. I have no issue with the quality of the MSC singers/dancers...or the variety. Because we were in YC...and could just come and go into the theatre, we saw each production twice back in April Entertainment is subjective....not everyone likes the same thing. That's why (on land) there are so many choices.

I understand that....but other cruselines are more generous.

Sol's doing fine...medically. But his balance is off...walks wobbly. I was "the butler" for him last week. A $50/pp obc and 10% fcc....not enuf compensation in my opinion. I just hope they have some good entertainment planned for you guys. Question....Sol and I have discussed this at length. Maybe you know. If 2 friends share a cabin, just friends....who gets the 10% FCC?

@mking8288 Just curious...but when you're anchored, will you be in international water? ...will the casino and shops be open?

The jury's in. Between a rise in price and a reduction of obc. ..it would be a $500 difference to change cabins. In addition....DH likes the pool.so "a cushioned rubber floor with no grip".....no thanks. I'm glad I read reviews..... IMHO....for various reasons this ship wouldn't have been a good fit.

One major difference....the pizza is great! I prefer MSC entertainment....more singing and dancing. None of those game shows...no comedians.. As far as the buffet ...I'm a big fan of the NCL buffet. Last time we sailed non-yacht club on msc was 2019, and I didn't care for their buffet (except for pizza....which i had multiple times a day).

Thanks.... I'm actually booked on the Lido...was so happy about that when I booked. I just aked TA if I could be reassigned without losing my OBC, If it's a "no".....then we'll probably cancel. I appreciate all the suggestions. The thing is....I'm not trying to solve a problem (go to MDR etc) but I'm trying to avoid a problem.

I am not a fan of Bermuda....water can be rough while at sea and Oct is past "the season". Since I enjoy the pool deck buffets, that sailing wouldn't be for me. (LOL...I'm on the next sailing to the Bahamas.) I'd go with the first cruise...for Ocean Cay. In either case, you'll get the full YC pampering experience!

I tried YC once ....and I'm hooked. I have 2 upcoming yacht club cruises booked. My husband's favorite port was freshly grilled fish for lunch poolside. Mine was customized pizza and coke delivered poolside by the butler! As far as entertainment....I love MSC's entertainment. So much better than "The Love Show" and the comedian on NCL Escape last week. At this point I don't see us sailing on NCL again. Although last week's cruise was fine (regular balcony)....it doesn't compare to a week in the YC.

The good news is that the weather here is supposed to be beautiful Friday -Sunday, so people can use the ship as a hotel and enjoy NYC.

Yacht club interior is the best value at sea, especially with the Voyagers Club discount! @bigdog1958He has one of those....if we end up doing this cruise he'll be taking it along.